Skip to content
Our Methodology

Every Snack Score Starts With a Blind 12-Person Taste Panel — Not an Algorithm, Not a Sponsor.

Before a single number appears next to a snack on this site, it has been bought at full retail price, broken open in our Austin kitchen, and scored blind by a panel of twelve tasters using a four-axis rubric: taste, price, macros, and availability. No paid placements, no asterisk, no exceptions.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Get My Free Snack List
2,847 Snacks reviewed & rated
12 Tasters per blind panel
4 Scoring axes, weighted
100% Bought at full retail
The Rubric

How a Snack Earns Its Score

Every snack in our database is graded on four axes. Each axis carries a fixed weight — meaning a 9.2 is not a feeling, it is a weighted math problem that any reader can replicate with the spreadsheet we publish below.

01

Taste

Weight: 40%

The blind panel rates each snack from 1 to 10 on flavor, texture, and the honest "would I eat this again on a Tuesday night" question. The twelve scores are averaged, outliers beyond two standard deviations are dropped, and the remaining mean becomes the axis score. A snack with no redeeming flavor — even at 80 calories — caps here at a 3.

02

Macros

Weight: 25%

Calories per serving sit at the floor of our rubric — anything over 150 cal per serving is disqualified from the database entirely. Above that floor, we score the protein-to-calorie ratio, fiber content, and added-sugar load. A 140-calorie cookie made with refined sugar and 1 gram of protein scores lower on macros than a 140-calorie Greek yogurt cup with 12 grams of protein, even at identical calories.

03

Price

Weight: 20%

We log the price per serving at three retailers: Amazon, Walmart, and one natural-foods store. The score reflects how the snack compares to the median price-per-serving in its category. A $4.99 single-serve bar when the category median is $2.49 loses points here. Price is real, not promotional — we do not record sale prices that are not available to a reader walking into a store today.

04

Availability

Weight: 15%

A 9.8 snack that is perpetually sold out at every online retailer and has never appeared on a Target shelf scores poorly here. We track whether the product is in stock at Amazon, available at one national grocery chain, and shipping within the contiguous U.S. All three boxes need to be checkable for a top-tier availability score.

Independence Policy

We Buy Every Snack. We Score Every Snack Blind. We Never Take a Brand's Money.

The whole site exists because of one rule: no paid placements. Ever. We do not run sponsored reviews, we do not accept free product, and we do not let a brand see its score before publication. Every bag, bar, and canister in our database was purchased at full retail price by a member of our team — usually with a personal credit card, usually at a H-E-B, Target, or on Amazon — and shipped to our Austin kitchen for the panel.

If a brand wants to send us a product to consider for review, we thank them, buy it on Amazon, and run it through the same blind process as every other snack. If they do not like the score, the score still publishes. In four years we have never edited a number to keep a brand happy, and we have walked away from six-figure partnership offers to keep it that way.

Meet the Founders
The Panel

Who Actually Does the Tasting

Twelve tasters per session, recruited from the Austin metro area and refreshed every six months so no single palate dominates the database. Three of the twelve are credentialed — two registered dietitians and one certified personal trainer. The remaining nine are screened for being real snack-eaters, not professional food writers.

01
Portrait of Mara, co-founder and registered dietitian

Mara, RD

Co-Founder · Registered Dietitian

Spent eight years as a Weight Watchers coach in Austin. Built the original 12-person tasting protocol in 2021 and still sits in on roughly one panel per week.

02
Portrait of Devon, co-founder and certified personal trainer

Devon, CPT

Co-Founder · Certified Personal Trainer

Six years coaching clients through strength and weight-loss programs. Leads the price-and-availability axis scoring and writes the weekly newsletter.

03
Portrait of Lin, registered dietitian on the taste panel

Lin, RD

Panel Lead · Registered Dietitian

Second registered dietitian on staff. Runs every Tuesday and Thursday panel session, manages the macro-axis scoring rubric, and vets every new dietary tag we add to the database.

04
Portrait of Priya, panel coordinator and data lead

Priya

Panel Coordinator · Data Lead

Recruits and screens every panelist, handles the blind-labeling process, and publishes the raw scoring spreadsheet for any reader who wants to verify a score themselves.

As featured in
2024 Healthline Stronger Than Diet-Culture Award Best Snack Review Site
Questions We Get A Lot

Skeptical Reader FAQ

If you have ever closed a "best snacks" list wondering whether the writer was paid to write it, these are the questions we would ask too — and the honest answers.

Do brands pay you to feature their snacks?

No. We have never accepted payment, free product, or any form of consideration from a snack brand in exchange for a review, a placement, or a score adjustment. Every snack in the database was purchased at full retail price. Brands sometimes send us their new launches as a courtesy, and our standard response is to thank them, buy it on Amazon, and score it through the same blind process as everything else.

How do I know scores do not quietly change after publication?

Scores are published with a timestamp and the raw panel spreadsheet. If we ever re-score a snack — which happens roughly once per quarter as reformulations and new packaging launch — we keep the original score visible and add a clearly labeled "Updated" entry with the date and the reason. The history is preserved on every snack page.

What about allergens and dietary restrictions?

Every snack in the database is tagged across 14 dietary categories including keto, gluten-free, vegan, dairy-free, and diabetic-friendly. The tags are verified against the product label at time of review and re-verified any time the brand reformulates. We do not assume — if the label is unclear, the tag does not get applied.

What disqualifies a snack from the database?

Three things: more than 150 calories per labeled serving, undisclosed proprietary blends that hide the macro breakdown, or repeated panel scores below 4.0 on taste. The calorie cap is hard — there is no exception for "but it has so much protein" — because the entire site exists to make the under-150 category easier to navigate.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Get My Free Snack List